Discussion
This study was conducted to analyse the biochemical and gene expression profiles of lung tissue samples in patients with IPF compared with a control group to identify metabolic and genetic biomarkers that may be targeted for the diagnosis and treatment of IPF. We believe that this is the first report that simultaneously and systemically measured the changes of metabolites involving seven metabolic pathways in human advantage of IPF lungs. We have shown various alterations in signalling pathways of sphingolipids, arginine, energy metabolism, haem and glutamate/aspartate metabolism, in patients with IPF compared with control. These pathways, when dysregulated, may underlie IPF pathogenesis.
Our results show downregulated SMPD1, SMPD4 and DEGS1, which point to disrupted ceramide production, whereas downregulated ACER3 and SPHK1 genes indicate disrupted S1P production. This suggests a change in the balance between levels of ceramide and S1P (the so-called ceramide/S1P rheostat), which has been shown to affect cell proliferation19 (Supplementary figure 5). Therefore, a change in the ceramide/S1P rheostat, as seen in our findings, indicates alterations in cell proliferation signalling, possibly for lung structural remodelling. Furthermore, S1P has been implicated in TGF-beta signalling.20 21 Extracellular S1P activates the Rho signalling cascade, which has been shown to cross-activate the connective tissue growth factor (CTGF).20 CTGF has been shown bind TGF-beta and is believed to be the downstream mediator of TGF-beta-induced fibrosis.22 However, intracellular S1P inhibits CTGF expression in vitro.23 This indicates that extracellular S1P enhances fibrosis through cross-activation of the TGF-beta signalling pathway whereas intracellular S1P inhibits it. Previously, Milara et al
24 found increased S1P in human IPF bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid and increased SPHK1 messenger RNA (mRNA) in human IPF BAL alveolar macrophages, which likely measured extracellular S1P. Our findings of reduced S1P as well as other sphingolipid metabolites are from the lung tissue. Also, we measured SPHK1 mRNA levels, whereas Milara et al measured SPHK1 protein levels in IPF lung tissue, this may account for the discrepancies in results. It would be interesting to confirm whether intracellular S1P is reduced in IPF lungs.
Our group found increases in arginine metabolites creatine, hydroxyproline and the putrescine and spermidine. Other groups have shown increased arginase expression or activity in either human IPF lung tissue or in bleomycin-induced mouse lung fibrosis models.25 26 Arginase converts arginine into ornithine, which is the precursor for proline–hydroxyproline and the polyamines putrescine and spermidine. Therefore, increases in these metabolites can be explained by upregulated arginase. Creatine is involved in energy metabolism. Creatine kinase transfers a phosphate group between ADP and creatine10 to generate ATP. Therefore, increased creatine in our results may be indicative of an upregulation of alternative ATP synthesis pathways to provide energy for lung structural remodelling.
Hydroxyproline is an important component of collagen for the extracellular matrix (ECM). Increased hydroxyproline levels in IPF are in accord with the increased ECM deposition in this disease. Polyamines have been shown to be involved in cell proliferation,11 27 and their depletion has been shown to arrest cell growth in HeLa cells by inhibiting protein synthesis.28 Therefore, increased polyamine levels in IPF lungs suggest increased cell proliferation. It is also interesting to note that fumarate and aspartate levels were found decreased. Since these metabolites also feed into the TCA cycle, increased arginine metabolism may be shuttling intermediates away from the TCA cycle and into ECM deposition and cell proliferation, possibly to support lung structural remodelling.
We found disrupted glycolysis in the IPF lung, with possible increases in the sorbitol and pentose phosphate pathways. Decreased glycolysis is in agreement with findings from Korfei et al,29 who found that GAPDH, PGK, phosphoglycerate mutase 1, TPI and LDHA were increased, whereas PKM, ENOA and FBP1 were decreased. While there was no comment on upregulated or downregulated glycolysis, it can be inferred that since PKM is a rate-limiting enzyme in glycolysis, their findings support reduced late-stage glycolysis, which is in agreement with our results. Discrepancies between our results may be due to other factors during translation or protein synthesis. We also found possible upregulation of the sorbitol and pentose phosphate pathways in IPF, hinting at the shuttling of glycolytic metabolites towards these pathways. Interestingly, in the pentose phosphate pathway, we found increased ribulose 5-phosphate, xylulose 5-phosphate and ribose, although the results were not significant. Korfei et al’s proteomic analysis also found decreased transketolase (TKT), which supports this idea. TKT metabolises xylulose 5-phosphate and ribose 5-phosphate, so its decrease would allow for the accumulation of ribulose 5-phosphate and xylulose 5-phosphate. Ribose is a precursor for nucleotide synthesis, and increased nucleotide synthesis may support cell proliferation and thereby lung structural remodelling in IPF.
We found accumulation of free fatty acids and reduced carnitine shuttle. Since fatty acids, especially longer chain fatty acids, require the carnitine shuttle to enter the mitochondria, this suggests reduced mitochondrial beta-oxidation in IPF. Furthermore, abnormal activity of very long-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (VLCAD), an enzyme involved in the beta-oxidation of very long-chain fatty acids, has been found in human IPF lung fibroblasts.30 However, since mitochondrial beta-oxidation of long-chain fatty acids is dependent on carnitine-mediated transport, a decrease in the carnitine-mediated transport would alter beta-oxidation, regardless of the activity of beta-oxidation enzymes. Overall, glycolysis, mitochondrial beta-oxidation and glucose oxidation via the TCA cycle are major cellular energy pathways. Their downregulation suggests that alternative energy pathways are upregulated to support cell growth and lung structural remodelling. Upregulated creatine metabolism may be an example of one such pathway.
Our findings of reduced haem and biliverdin levels in IPF, together with increased bilirubin levels, suggest increased haem degradation to produce bilirubin. Previously, Nakamura et al
31 found that increasing HO-1 levels reduces TGF-beta-stimulated collagen production in vitro via carbon monoxide (CO) rather than bilirubin, whereas Atzori et al
32 found that increased HO-1 attenuates fibrosis in bleomycin-induced mouse lung fibrosis models. Our findings of decreased haem levels may therefore result in reduced CO. Since CO can inhibit TGF-beta-induced fibrogenesis, reduced haem and therefore CO levels may contribute to fibrosis. Oxidative stress has been proposed to play a role in IPF pathogenesis, possibly by inducing alveolar epithelial injury.33 Indeed, lung epithelial cells of patients with interstitial pneumonia have been found to contain higher levels of oxidants than normal tissue.34 Bilirubin is an antioxidant and has been shown to attenuate bleomycin-induced rat pulmonary fibrosis.35 Therefore, our findings of increased bilirubin may be due to attempting to reduce oxidative stress in IPF.
Our group found increased glutamine and glutamate and decreased aspartate levels in IPF lungs, although the changes were not significant. Since this pathway is an anaplerotic pathway to generate intermediates for the TCA cycle changes in this pathways may account for the reduced TCA cycle metabolites in IPF. We also found increased levels of the antioxidant glutathione (GSH, the reduced form) and decreased levels of its oxidised counterpart GSSG in IPF lungs. This supports previous findings that bleomycin activates the oxidative stress response in the bleomycin-induced mouse lung fibrosis model and upregulates GSH. Liu et al
36 also found that GSH levels were initially suppressed by overexpression of TGF-beta in mouse lungs, but later returned to normal, possibly implicating GSH in a response to fibrosis. Our findings may therefore reflect the body’s attempt to generate more GSH as part of the oxidative stress response in IPF.2
Study limitations
The number of subjects in the current study is relatively limited. However, our sample size is equivalent to similar studies in this field as it is very difficult to obtain fresh human IPF lungs. Although the tissues for all studies were collected within 2 years, this short period may still be a limitation to obtaining more tissue for both metabolomics and transcription study.
The results of this study support a greater understanding of the metabolic basis of pathogenesis of IPF formation. From a clinical perspective, this may translate to new developments of methods to assess IPF metabolism (as a predictor of prognosis or as a way to assess the efficacy of IPF targeted therapy).
Finally, understanding the metabolic pathways in the development of IPF provides the possibility of exploring the effects of metabolic modulation as a potential therapeutic strategy in the treatment or prevention of IPF.