Discussion
We assessed the clinical characteristics, radiologic findings and outcome of pulmonary cryptococcosis in patients with RA. Minor clinical differences were observed between the patients with and without RA, although no significant differences were observed in the frequencies of meningitis and respiratory failure and radiological findings. All but one patient with RA had a favourable outcome. Administration of antirheumatic drugs during and after treatment for cryptococcosis had no negative effects on the clinical course of antifungal treatment in terms of rate of treatment success and recurrence.
Among the patients with pulmonary cryptococcosis, 21.2% had RA. The prevalence of RA in Japan was estimated at between 0.6% and 1.0%.18 However, the proportion of patients with RA with pulmonary cryptococcosis in this study was much higher than the prevalence of RA in the general population. C. neoformans is a facultative intracellular pathogen, and one important protective function against infection is cellular immunity.19 Host defence against C. neoformans infection is mediated by T helper type 1 cellular immunity, which is triggered by host cell recognition of the pathogen-associated molecular pattern recognition receptors.20 Rheumatoid inflammation is suggested to be mediated by activated proinflammatory T helper type 1 cells, and thus, the impaired host as defined by patients with RA may contribute to the high prevalence of pulmonary cryptococcosis. We also found that patients with RA with pulmonary cryptococcosis were predominantly female and older than the patients without RA. Many studies of pulmonary cryptococcosis have shown male predominance or almost equal numbers of males and females.21 22 Our findings may reflect the higher age and female predominance observed in the RA population overall.
Fever was the most common presenting symptom, and the WBC counts and CRP levels were significantly higher in the patients with RA. Fever was less frequent (0%–25%) among patients with pulmonary cryptococcosis without HIV infection.21 22 Yanagawa et al reported that hyper-reaction to organisms was seen in pulmonary cryptococcosis with patients with RA pathologically and was different from the reaction protecting against infection.12 This reaction was also reported in patients with RA with Pneumocystis pneumonia.23 Moreover, because 7 of the 11 patients with RA were taking steroid, WBCs might have been elevated due to this drug. Also, CRP might be one of the inflammatory markers of RA itself.
Chest CT imaging showed consolidation to be the most common finding, although no significant differences in any findings were observed between the patients with and without RA. Among immunocompetent patients and individuals without AIDS, the most common CT feature was the presence of multiple peripherally distributed pulmonary nodules or masses with predominantly lower lobe involvement,15 21 24–28 although the number of nodules or masses in previous reports has varied. Cavitation in nodules or masses and pleural effusion have been previously described as radiographic features limited to immunosuppressed patients.29 30 However, consolidation and ground-glass attenuation were the main radiologic features in patients with RA, with no differences in the frequency of cavitary lesions and pleural effusion, which were compatible with our results. Among seven reported patients who received anti-TNF biological therapy, including our patient, three (42.9%) showed a consolidation pattern, one (14.3%) had multiple nodules and two (28.6%) showed a solidary nodule/mass pattern. RA itself and treatment for RA may not necessarily affect the variation in radiologic findings.
Among our patients with RA, 72.7% received FLCZ, and the remainder received FLCZ and 5-FC. All but one patient improved and did not have recurrence of cryptococcosis. The guidelines for cryptococcosis management in Japan recommend FLCZ for 3–6 months in patients without central nervous system involvement.31 Conversely, the Infectious Diseases Society of America guideline for pulmonary cryptococcosis in non-immunosuppressed patients without HIV states that for mild-to-moderate symptoms, FLCZ (400 mg/day orally) should be administered for 6–12 months.32 All of our patients with RA without meningitis received FLCZ ± 5 FC for <9 months, whereas one patient with meningitis received it for 61 months. No patients, including two in whom FLCZ was withdrawn at 3 and 4.5 months, respectively, due to side effects, experienced disease recurrence. These findings suggested that the duration of treatments as recommended in the Japanese guidelines31 may also be appropriate in patients with RA. Further studies are needed to determine the optimal duration of treatment for cryptococcosis in patients with RA .
Cryptococcosis is a severe fungal infection with high mortality rate among organ transplant recipients and patients with AIDS.33 In contrast, several studies have shown favourable outcomes of pulmonary cryptococcosis among patients without HIV.15 16 Only two (3.8%) of our patients died during the course of antifungal treatment, including one patient each in the RA and non-RA groups. The patient with RA died due to pulmonary cryptococcosis, and the patient without RA complicated with meningitis developed aspiration pneumonia and deteriorated to death. Pulmonary cryptococcosis itself could be a fatal infectious complication in patients with RA. Due to the small sample number in the present study, further investigation is required into differences in mortality between patients with and without RA.
Several studies have shown that the occurrence of opportunistic infection was significantly higher in patients with RA who received TNF blockage therapy.13 34 As TNF production is critical in the immune response against cryptococcal infection,35 depletion of TNF by treatment with TNF blockage therapy might facilitate the development of cryptococcosis. Seven cases, including our case, have been reported of pulmonary cryptococcosis complicated with RA in patients receiving TNF blockage therapy.5–10 Among them, cryptococcosis occurred within 6 months of initiating biologics in all cases, suggesting that infectious complications can occur early. All patients responded well to antifungal treatment. It is important that physicians include pulmonary cryptococcosis in the differential diagnosis when they encounter patients with RA with compatible radiological findings or clinical findings with pulmonary cryptococcosis in an early stage after initiation of TNF blockage therapy.
Long-term administration of immunosuppressant drugs carries the risk of several complications and can result in subsequent or prolonged infection. It is not clear whether immunosuppressant drugs can be continued when developing cryptococcal infections and whether antirheumatic drugs can be used safely and efficiently in such situations. The present study showed that rheumatologists hesitated to continue antirheumatic drugs that were administered prior to the cryptococcosis diagnosis during antifungal treatment. RA activities in our patients worsened with discontinuation of the antirheumatic drugs. Their readministration had no negative effects on the clinical course of antifungal treatment and did not increase the risk of relapse of cryptococcosis. From the present results, we believe that it is reasonable to assume that antirheumatic drugs could be continued during antifungal treatment for cryptococcosis. Further studies are needed to establish adequate strategies for treating RA when developing cryptococcosis.
This study has several limitations. First, it is a single-centre retrospective study, which reduces the level of confidence, and the results may not be applicable in other settings. Second, the small sample size makes it difficult to draw any firm conclusions. It may be premature to draw a conclusion that the administration of antirheumatic drugs during and after the development of pulmonary cryptococcosis in patients with RA is safe. The accumulation of more cases and the conduction of further investigations are needed in the future. Third, we did not investigate disease severity of RA because RA severity at the onset of cryptococcosis was noted in only a few of the patients’ medical records.
In conclusion, a high prevalence of patients with RA with pulmonary cryptococcosis was noted. Only minimal differences were found in the clinical and radiological findings of the patients with and without RA. The administration of antirheumatic therapy during and after treatment for cryptococcosis did not negatively affect the clinical course of antifungal treatment. Further studies are needed to clarify the safety of antirheumatic drugs in patients with RA after the diagnosis of cryptococcosis and the optimal treatment approaches for cryptococcosis in the patients with RA.