Table 1

Effect direction plot summarising direction of outcome domains of included studies

StudyStudy designSymptoms (validated)Symptoms (non-validated)Objective measuresHealthcare utilisation
Hatzelis et al, 201237CS
Nacci et al39
2011
O/U
Pinho et al,42
1997
CS
Baxter et al,
201934
O/U◄►
Haines et al,
201635
O/U
Halevi-Katz,
201936
O/U◄►
Krammer et al, 201733O/C
Marcinow et al, 201518O/U
Mathers-Schmidt & Brilla, 200522CS◄►
Murry et al,
201038
O/U◄►
Olley et al,
201340
O/U
Pargeter & Mansur, 201641O/U
Shin et al,
201843
O/U◄►
Warnes et al, 200544CS
  • Study design: O/U observational non-randomised uncontrolled before and after; O/C observational non-randomised controlled before and after; CS case study.

  • Effect direction: upward arrow ▲=positive impact; downward arrow ▼=negative impact; sideways arrow ◄►=no change/mixed effects/conflicting findings.

  • Sample size: final sample size (individuals) in intervention group. Large arrow ▲>300; medium arrow ▲ 50–300; small arrow ▲<50.

  • Study quality: denoted by row colour and JBI ratings assigned: green=low risk of bias; amber=some concerns; red=high risk of bias.