Table 3

Number of concordant and discordant interpretations for abnormal FEV1 (FEV1<LLN) when using Canadian reference equation compared with GLI-Race or GLI-Other equation*

EthnicityGLI-RaceTotalGLI-OtherTotal
FEV1≥LLNFEV1<LLNFEV1≥LLNFEV1<LLN
AllCanadianCanadian
FEV1≥LLN285 (70.2%)1 (0.2%)286FEV1≥LLN286 (70.4%)0 (0%)286
FEV1<LLN49 (12.1%)71 (17.5%)120FEV1<LLN59 (14.5%)61 (15.0%)120
Total33472406Total34561406
CaucasianCanadianCanadian
FEV1≥LLN178 (77.7%)0 (0%)178FEV1≥LLN178 (77.7%)0 (0%)178
FEV1<LLN14 (6.1%)37 (16.2%)51FEV1<LLN29 (12.7%)22 (9.6%)51
Total19237229Total20722229
BlackCanadianCanadian
FEV1≥LLN8 (40.0%)0 (0%)8FEV1≥LLN8 (40.0%)0 (0%)8
FEV1<LLN10 (50.0%)2 (10.0%)12FEV1<LLN5 (25.0%)7 (35.0%)12
Total18220Total13720
NE AsianCanadianCanadian
FEV1≥LLN12 (57.1%)1 (4.8%)13FEV1≥LLN13 (61.9%)0 (0%)13
FEV1<LLN1 (4.8%)7 (33.3%)8FEV1<LLN5 (23.8%)3 (14.3%)8
Total13821Total18321
SE AsianCanadianCanadian
FEV1≥LLN62 (67.4%)0 (0%)62FEV1≥LLN62 (67.4%)0 (0%)62
FEV1<LLN16 (17.4%)14 (15.2%)30FEV1<LLN12 (13.0%)18 (19.6%)30
Total781492Total741892
Other/MixedCanadianCanadian
FEV1≥LLN25 (56.8%)0 (0%)25FEV1≥LLN25 (56.8%)0 (0%)25
FEV1<LLN8 (18.2%)11 (25.0%)19FEV1<LLN8 (18.2%)11 (25.0%)19
Total331144Total331144
  • *We analysed the data by classifying Asian participants as NE Asian (model 1) if they could not be classified clearly as either NE Asian or SE Asian.

  • FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1 s; GLI, Global Lung Function Initiative; LLN, lower limit of normal; NE, North East; SE, South East.