Table 3

Quality of evidence for overall and subgroup analyses

Overall and subgroup analysesNumber of studiesOR95% CIQuality of evidence
Overall6–17 19–21 29–36231.381.10 to 1.74⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Cohort studies6 7 21 29 3251.731.16 to 2.57⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Cross-sectional studies8–17 19 20 30 31 33–36181.201.14 to 1.28⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Insufficient sleep duration8 9 11 13–17 19–21 30 31 33141.201.13 to 1.28⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Poor sleep quality8–12 29 3471.101.05 to 1.16⨁⨁〇〇
Low
Adults6–8 14 17 20 31 33 34 36101.361.18 to 1.57⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Adolescents10 15 16 19 21 29 30 3581.151.08 to 1.21⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Children9 11 1231.130.97 to 1.32⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Studies conducted in Europe and America7 11 19–21 31 34 3581.341.21 to 1.48⨁⨁〇〇
Low
Studies conducted in Asia6 8–10 12–16 29 32111.211.12 to 1.31⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Studies in which BMI was adjusted7 9 13–16 20 21 30 33 34111.221.13 to 1.31⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Studies in which BMI was not adjusted6 8 10–12 17 19 29 31 32 35 36121.291.14 to 1.47⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
Studies in which family history of asthma was adjusted12 2121.160.94 to 1.42〇〇〇〇
Very Low
Studies in which family history of asthma was not adjusted6–11 13–17 19 20 29–36211.271.18 to 1.36⨁〇〇〇
Very Low
  • BMI, body mass index.