Table 1

Inclusion/exclusion criteria

Inclusion criteriaExclusion criteria
  • Randomised controlled-trials, cohort studies, case–control studies and case series including greater than five patients.

  • Human studies only.

  • If multiple articles had overlapping cohorts (determined by institution and year), only the most recent publication was included.

  • Reports published in English language.

  • Individual case reports and case series with fewer than five patients included.

  • Articles describing technical aspects of surgical technique or those that purely reported on perioperative or short term outcomes.

  • Animal studies.

  • Publications that described surgical techniques that differ significantly from current techniques were excluded; in practice, this removed all publication prior to 1989.